Why You Keep
Starting Over​
(And How to Finally Follow Through)

Do the Hard Things First Newsletter

​​​​​​​

You've started this before.

The diet. The workout routine. The morning practice. The project. The habit.

You started with energy. With commitment. With the certainty that this time would be different.

And then, somewhere along the way, you stopped. Life happened. Motivation faded. You fell off.

Now you're starting over. Again.

The restart cycle is one of the most exhausting patterns in personal development. You make progress, lose it, and begin again—never building on what came before. Always back to zero.

Here's the truth: The problem isn't that you keep failing. The problem is how you respond to failure.

The Anatomy of the Restart Cycle

The cycle looks like this:

Phase 1: The Exciting Start You're motivated. You have a plan. You feel different this time. The first few days or weeks go well.

Phase 2: The Resistance The novelty wears off. It gets hard. You miss a day. Then another. The internal negotiation begins.

Phase 3: The Collapse You miss enough that the habit feels broken. Guilt sets in. You avoid thinking about it. The thing you were building quietly dies.

Phase 4: The Reset Weeks or months later, you decide to start again. "This time will be different." You're back at Phase 1.

Sound familiar?

The problem isn't Phase 2 or even Phase 3. Those are normal. The problem is that Phase 4 takes you back to zero instead of building on what you learned.

Use the promo code proc50 to begin your training at 50% off the price

Why You Keep Restarting

Several patterns fuel the restart cycle:

All-or-nothing thinking. You believe you're either "on" or "off." One slip means total failure. So when you miss a few days, you don't course-correct—you collapse entirely and wait for the next "fresh start."

The clean slate fantasy. Starting over feels good. It's full of possibility. There's no failure yet, no disappointing history. You get addicted to the feeling of beginning rather than the reality of continuing.

Avoiding the messy middle. The beginning is exciting. The end is rewarding. The middle is just work. Restarting lets you skip the middle—over and over.

No system for recovery. You have a plan for when things go well. You have no plan for when they don't. So when you stumble, you don't know what to do except quit and restart later.

Mistaking intensity for commitment. You start with extreme effort—wake up at 5 AM, work out for 90 minutes, overhaul your entire diet. This isn't sustainable. When intensity fades, you interpret it as failure rather than a signal to adjust.

The Shift: From Restarting to Recovering

The people who build lasting change don't avoid failure. They recover from it differently.

Restarting = Treating every stumble as a total reset. Going back to Day 1. Losing all momentum.

Recovering = Treating stumbles as part of the process. Getting back on track immediately. Building on what came before.

The difference isn't willpower. It's mindset and systems.

How to Break the Restart Cycle

1. Adopt the "Never Miss Twice" Rule

You will miss. Accept that now.

The goal isn't perfect consistency. The goal is never missing twice in a row.

Miss a workout? Fine. Do something—anything—the next day.

Skip your morning routine? Okay. Protect it tomorrow no matter what.

One miss is a stumble. Two misses is a slide. Three misses is a new pattern.

Protect against the second miss like your progress depends on it. Because it does.

2. Lower the Bar When You're Struggling

When you're in Phase 2 (resistance), don't try to maintain your peak intensity. Lower the bar.

Can't do the full workout? Do 10 minutes.

Can't write 1000 words? Write 100.

Can't do your whole morning routine? Do the two most important pieces.

A minimum viable effort keeps the habit alive. You can raise the bar again when conditions improve. But the habit must survive—and survival beats optimization.

3. Remove the "Fresh Start" Option

Stop waiting for Monday. Stop waiting for the first of the month. Stop waiting for a "clean" restart point.

The best time to get back on track is immediately.

If you fell off this morning, get back on this afternoon. If you fell off yesterday, today is the day. Not next week. Not next month. Now.

The "fresh start" is a trap. It feels productive but it's just delay with extra steps.

4. Track Streaks, Not Perfection

Don't track whether you did something perfectly. Track how many days you showed up.

And when you break the streak, don't erase everything. Note the streak length, then start building the next one.

Over time, you'll see your streaks getting longer. That's progress—even with breaks in between.

Progress isn't a straight line. It's an upward trend with dips.

5. Plan for Recovery in Advance

Before you start any new habit or project, answer these questions:

• What will I do when I miss a day?
• What's the minimum version I can do when I'm struggling?
• What are my high-risk situations for falling off?
• How will I get back on track without waiting for a "fresh start"?

If you only have a plan for success, you're not prepared. The recovery plan is as important as the action plan.

The Continuity Mindset

Here's the mental shift that changes everything:

You're not starting over. You're continuing.

Every past attempt taught you something. Every failure revealed a weakness in your system. Every restart gave you data about what doesn't work.

You're not at zero. You're further along than someone who's never tried.

When you "start again," you're not beginning from scratch. You're picking up where you left off—wiser than before.

Stop treating your history as failure. Start treating it as research.

The Recovery Protocol

When you fall off (and you will), use this:

Step 1: Notice without judgment. "I stopped doing the thing. That happened. Okay."

Step 2: Identify what caused it. Not to blame yourself—to understand. What triggered the slide? What was missing?

Step 3: Do the minimum today. Not tomorrow. Not Monday. Today. Even 5 minutes counts.

Step 4: Adjust the system. What needs to change so this is less likely to happen again? Lower the bar? Different time? More accountability?

Step 5: Continue. You're not restarting. You're continuing. The streak broke, but the practice didn't.

Your Next Step

Think about something you've started and stopped multiple times.

Answer honestly:

1. How many times have I "restarted" this?
2. What pattern keeps causing me to stop?
3. What would "recovering" instead of "restarting" look like?
4. What's my minimum viable version for when I'm struggling?

Now: If you've fallen off something, get back on today. Not Monday. Today.

The goal isn't to never fall. The goal is to get back up so fast that falling barely matters.

Go Deeper

Breaking the restart cycle is about doing hard things first—especially the hard thing of continuing when you'd rather quit and start fresh. Do the Hard Things First gives you the system for building consistency that survives the inevitable stumbles.

→ Get it at scottallanbooks.com​
​The Discipline Accelerator

Use Promotional code founding50 to grab your discount, limited to the first 50 buyers.

​scottallanacademy.com​

When You’re Ready, Here’s How I Can Help You:

$5.00 Scott Allan Hi, I'm Scott Allan... Thank You for Your Support! Your encouragement and support mean the world to me. If you’ve found... Read more Send a tip

​