Why Most Resolutions Die by January 15th

Why Most Resolutions Die by January 15th

The Identity Trap That Keeps You Stuck in the Same Loop Every Year

​​​​​​​​​

Every January, I watched the same ritual.

The gym packed to capacity on January 2nd. Standing room only. People fighting for treadmills. By January 20th? Tumbleweeds.

For years, I was one of those people. I'd make the resolution. Feel the surge of motivation on New Year's Day. Write out my goals in a fresh journal. And then—without fail—I'd be back to my old patterns before the month ended.

I thought I lacked discipline. Willpower. Maybe I just wasn't the kind of person who could change.

Then I realized: I wasn't solving the wrong problem. I was solving the wrong person.

Available Now: The 30-Day "Do the Hard Things First" Challenge: A Course by Scott Allan

Ready to build permanent courage through systematic fear-facing? Join our 30-Day Do the Hard Things First Challenge where you'll progressively build courage through daily micro-doses of scary actions. Learn the exact protocols elite performers use to transform fear into fuel and build unshakeable confidence. Sign up here and start compounding courage today by doing the hard things everyday

​Join the 30-Day Challenge and get 10% off when you use this Coupon Code: proc28

THE TRUTH (INSIGHT & REFRAME):

Here's what nobody tells you about New Year's resolutions: 93% of them fail. Not because people are weak. Not because they don't want it badly enough. But because they're trying to install new software on a broken operating system.

Think about it. Every year you say, "I'm going to lose weight." "I'm going to wake up earlier." "I'm going to finally write that book."

And every year, you're trying to bolt those behaviors onto the same identity that created the problems in the first place.

The person who stays up until 2 AM scrolling social media cannot become an early riser through willpower alone. The identity has to shift first. The operating system has to be rewritten.

This is the resolution trap: You're trying to change what you do without changing who you are.

Here's the contrarian truth that transformed everything for me: Stop making resolutions. Start making identity decisions.

A resolution says, "I want to lose weight."
An identity decision says, "I am someone who moves their body daily."

A resolution says, "I want to read more."
An identity decision says, "I am a reader."

A resolution says, "I want to be more disciplined."
An identity decision says, "I am someone who does hard things first."

The first is a wish. The second is a claim on who you are. And your brain will work overtime to maintain consistency with who you believe yourself to be.

FRAMEWORK: The I.D.E.A. Method

Here's a framework to make identity-first transformation actually work:

I = Identify the Identity Gap

Look at the behaviors you've failed to maintain. Behind every failed resolution is an identity mismatch. Ask yourself: "What kind of person naturally does the thing I'm trying to force myself to do?"

If you want to exercise consistently, the identity isn't "someone who exercises." It's "an athlete." Or "someone who respects their body." Or "a person who prioritizes physical strength."

Find the identity that resonates. The one that feels like an upgrade, not an obligation.

D = Declare It Present Tense

This is crucial. You're not becoming this person someday. You're claiming it now.

Not "I want to be disciplined." Instead: "I am disciplined."​
Not "I'm trying to be a writer." Instead: "I am a writer."

Your brain doesn't differentiate between who you are and who you claim to be. Start claiming.

E = Evidence Collection

Your brain needs proof. It's skeptical of sudden identity shifts. So your job is to find evidence from your past that supports your new identity.

Think you're not disciplined? What about that time you completed a project under a tight deadline? What about the habits you've maintained without even thinking about them?

Collect the evidence. Your past is full of moments that prove you can be who you're deciding to become.

A = Activate Through Action

Identity without action is just fantasy. Every day, ask yourself: "What would someone with my new identity do right now?"

Would a disciplined person hit snooze? Would an athlete skip their workout? Would a writer spend their morning on social media?

Then act accordingly. Small actions, repeated daily, become the proof that rewires your self-concept.

YOUR NEXT STEP:

Here's your action for today—and I mean today, not January 1st:

Write down 3 behaviors you've failed to maintain in the past.

Now, for each one, answer this question: "What identity would make this behavior automatic?"

Reframe each resolution as an identity statement. Present tense. Declarative.

Then pick one. Just one. And for the next 7 days, ask yourself every morning: "What would this person do today?"

That's it. No massive overhaul. No complicated system. Just one identity decision, lived out through daily action.

THE BIGGER PICTURE:

This newsletter kicks off a 7-part series called "The 6-Month Transformation."

Over the next two weeks, I'm going to walk you through exactly how to rewire your operating system so that six months from now, you won't recognize yourself.

Not through willpower. Not through motivation. Through identity architecture.

Here's what's coming:

• Newsletter 2: "The 72-Hour Identity Shift" — Why waiting for January 1st is the script talking
• Newsletter 3: "Embrace the Suck" — How discomfort is the mechanism, not the obstacle
• Newsletter 4: "The Identity Stack" — Building your daily non-negotiables
• Newsletter 5: "The Morning Crucible" — Win the first hour, win the year
• Newsletter 6: "The 1% Hard Thing Protocol" — Systematic daily challenge
• Newsletter 7: "Who Will You Be in June?" — The commitment that changes everything

This isn't motivational fluff. This is the strategic rebellion you've been waiting for.

Let's escape the script together.

Course Launching Soon:
​The Discipline Accelerator

​

​